| Zombie of the Year | K. Rasmussen |
| Favorite Writer | J. Bratcher |
| Favorite Artist | S. Rankin |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Westchester Menshevik (T. Stieve) |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 224 (S. Rankin) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 226 (April) |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Ed Brubaker |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Oclair Albert & Tom Palmer (tie) |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Angel; Captain America; Casanova; Hulk; Korvus; Rogue; Ampersand; Beta George; Black Canary; Howard the Duck; Huntress; Ultimate Spider-Man; Wolverine; Buffy; Dazzler; Ed Elric; Scott Pilgrim; Spider-Girl; Superman |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | Buffy Season 8 (Dark Horse) |
| Favorite New Comics Series | Buffy Season 8 (Dark Horse) |
| Worst Comics Series | Spider-Man: One More Day (Marvel) |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Pearls Before Swine |
| Zombie of the Year | S. Hutchison |
| Favorite Writer | J. Bratcher |
| Favorite Artist | L. Brown |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Westchester Menshevik (T. Stieve) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Farmers Other Almanac No. 108 (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Newcomer | J. Little |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 220 (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 220 (October) |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Purity Stolen (J. Bratcher) |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Gail Simone |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Alex Garner; Scott Hanna; Paul Neary; Art Thibert; George Perez; Jimmy Palmiotti; Dexter Vines; Chris Bachalo; Doug Hazelwood |
| Favorite Cover Artist | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Chris Bachalo; Mark Bagley; Adam Hughes; George Perez; Al Rio; Alex Ross; Simon Bianchi; Brett Booth; John Cassaday; Jeremy Haun; Michael Avon Oeming; Frank Cho; Barry Kitson; Jim Lee; Joe Quesada; Ethan van Scriver |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Spider-Man |
| Favorite Supporting Character | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Alfred; Bigby Wolf; Chas; Female Peter Parker clone; Juggernaut; Lockheed; Mary Jane Watson-Parker; Casey; Catwoman; Colossus; Ragamuffin; Sasha Bordeaux; Tonto; Ultimate Kitty PRyde; Ultimate Mary Jane Watson; Willy McCoy; Jarvis; Kon; Urd |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | New Avengers (Marvel) |
| Favorite Limited Series | 52 (DC) & Spike vs. Dracula (IDW) (tie) |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: American Born Chinese; The 49ers; The Fountain; Fun House; Hyperion I; Spike: Old Times; Wonderful Wizard of Oz; Bus Gamer: The Pilot Edition; I 'Heart' Marvel; Scott Pilgrim & the Infinite Sadness; Angel: Masks; G.I. Joe: Scarlett Declassified |
| Favorite Collected Edition | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Absolute Sandman; Avengers Disassembled; Bomb Queen: Woman of Mass Destruction; Hellboy: The Norm; Inverloch; Rabbi's Cat; Saiyuki Reload Vol. 6; Seven Solderies; Sur les terres d'Horus; Ultimates Vol. 2; Hellboy: Strange Ways; Het Zwaard van Iskander; Inverloch Vol. 2; Phantom Sundays; Saiyuki Reload Vol. 5; Spide vs. Dracula; Crisis on Infinite Earths; Death Jr.; Full Metal Alchemist; Spike |
| Favorite Independent Comic | Fell (Image) |
| Favorite New Comics Series | 52 (DC) |
| Worst Comics Series | Hawkgirl (DC) |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Batman Begins & Sin City (tie) |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Get Fuzzy |
| Hall of Fame | I. Martin |
| Zombie of the Year | S. Hutchison |
| Favorite Writer | J. Bratcher |
| Favorite Artist | L. Brown |
| Favorite Regular Zine | XING |
| Favorite Single Zine | Eclectic No. 108 |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 208 (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 200 (February) |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Worst Night Ever (J. Bratcher) |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Brian Michael Bendis |
| Favorite Comics Artist | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Chris Bachalo; Jim Lee; Ted Naifeh; George Perez; David Finch; Kosuke Fujishima; Bryan Hitch; Terry Moore; Mark Buckingham; Naomi Fearn; Masakazu Katsura; Greg Land |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Steve Leialoha |
| Favorite Cover Artist | Mike Grell & Adam Hughes (tie) |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Black Canary |
| Favorite Supporting Character | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Mary Jane Watson-Parker; Oracle; Rogue; Andy (of She-Hulk); Beast Boy; Timber Wolf; Lady Tomoe; Miss Mzak |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Legion of Superheroes; Spider-Girl; Strangers in Paradise; Daredevil; Ultimate Spider-Man; Ultimates; Birds of Prey; Ex-Machina; Usagi Yojimbo; Wolverine; Mosaik; New Avegngers; Ultimate Fantastic Four |
| Favorite Limited Series | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Astro City: Dark Age; GLA Disassembled; Serenity; Wildcats: Nemesis; Angel: THe Curse; Last Hero Standing; Stardust Kid; X-Men: Age of Apocalypse; Battle Hymn; Captain Gravity & the Power of the Vril; Jon Sable; Malet |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Courtney Crumrin Tales; Ronin Hood & the 47 Samurai; Love as a Foreign Language |
| Favorite Collected Edition | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Ghost in the Shell 2: Man-Machine Interface; Sayuki Reload; (Essential) Werewolf By Night; Hellsing; Neotopia; Sayuki Vol. 9; Ultimate Spider-Man Vol. 14 |
| Favorite Independent Comic | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Fell; Usagi Yojimbo; Amelia Rules; Conan; Astro City; Super Manga Blast |
| Favorite New Comics Series | *No winner* |
| | Receiving votes: Fell; Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man; Supergirl; Legion of Superheroes; She-Hulk; Villains United; Red Sonja; Simpson's Super Spectacular |
| Worst Comics Series | Amzing Spider-Man (Marvel) |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Batman Begins & Sin City (tie) |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Get Fuzzy |
| Hall of Fame | *No winner* |
| Zombie of the Year | I. Martin |
| Favorite Writer | J. Bratcher |
| Favorite Artist | L. Brown |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theatre (M. Jacot) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Guest Artist Extravaganza (L. Brown) |
| Best Newcomer | C. Caywood |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 197 (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 190 (April) |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Sassafras Zombie Squad (M. Tart) |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Brian Michael Bendis |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Paul Neary |
| Favorite Cover Artist | Alex Ross |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Spider-Man |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Get Fuzzy |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | Astonishing X-Men (Marvel) |
| Favorite Limited Series | Identity Crisis (DC) |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | Sandman: Endless Nights (DC) |
| Favorite Collected Edition | Love Fights Vol. 1 (Oni Press) |
| Favorite Independent Comic | [6 way tie] - Conan (Dark Horse)/Hellboy (Dark Horse)/Panik Elektro (European)/Suiyuki (Tokyopop)/Usagi Yojimbo (Dark Horse)/Strangers in Paradise (Abstract Studio) |
| Favorite New Comics Series | Astonishing X-Men (Marvel) |
| Worst Comics Series | Marvel Knights Spider-Man (Marvel) |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Spider-Man 2 |
| Hall of Fame | M. Jacot |
| Zombie of the Year | I. Martin |
| Favorite Writer | A. Olin |
| Favorite Artist | M. Jacot |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Eclectic (A. Olin) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theatre No. 100 (M. Jacot) |
| Best Newcomer | Y. Tolbert |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 180 (S. Haan) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 184 (October) |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Sassafras Zombie Squad (M. Tart) |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Brian Michael Bendis |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Paul Neary |
| Favorite Cover Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Batman |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Get Fuzzy |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | Marvel |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | Ultimates (Marvel) |
| Favorite Limited Series | JLA/Avengers (DC/Marvel) |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | Sandman: Endless Nights (DC) |
| Favorite Collected Edition | Halo & Sprocket (Amaze Ink) |
| Favorite Black and White Comic | [6 way tie] - Cerebus (Aardvark Vanheim)/Hellsing (Dark Horse)/Lenore (Slave Labor)/Love Fights (Oni Press)/Road to Perdition II/Strangers in Paradise |
| Best New Comics Series | Outsiders (DC) |
| Worst Comics Series | Marville (Marvel) |
| Favorite Revival | [4 way tie] - Formerly Known as the Justice League (DC)/Shang Chi (Marvel)/Spider-Girl (Marvel)/Ultimates (Marvel) |
| Favorite Comics Movie | X2 |
| Hall of Fame | S. Haan |
| Zombie of the Year | I. Martin |
| Favorite Writer | A. Olin |
| Favorite Artist | M. Jacot |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theatre (M. Jacot) |
| Favorite Single Zine | The Farmer's Other Almanac Guest Artist Extravaganza (L. Brown) |
| Best Newcomer | Osiris |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 173 (S. Rankin) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 173 |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Sassafras Zombie Squad (M. Tart) |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Brian Michael Bendis |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Terry Austin/Drew Geraci/Tom Palmer/Al Vey |
| Favorite Cover Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Spider-Man |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Get Fuzzy |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | JSA |
| Favorite Limited Series | The Thessaliad |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | Harlequin Valentine |
| Favorite Collected Edition | 100 Bullets |
| Favorite Black and White Comic | Usagi Yojimbo |
| Best New Comics Series | Ultimates |
| Worst Comics Series | Cage |
| Favorite Revival | Howard the Duck |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Spider-Man |
| Hall of Fame | P. Guthrie |
| Zombie of the Year | I. Martin |
| Favorite Writer | A. Olin |
| Favorite Artist | L. Brown |
| Favorite Regular Zine | The Farmer's Other Almanac (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Eclectic #78 (A. Olin) |
| Best Newcomer | S. Sellers & J. Bratcher |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 156 (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 154 |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Dung (M. Lucas) |
| Favorite Comics Writer | J. Michael Straczynski |
| Favorite Comics Artist | John Romita, Jr. |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Al Williamson |
| Favorite Cover Artist | Adam Hughes |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Spider-Man |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Get Fuzzy |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | Amazing Spider-Man |
| Favorite Limited Series | Daredevil: Yellow |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | Heroes |
| Favorite Collected Edition | League of Extraordinary Gentlemen |
| Best New Comics Series | Green Arrow |
| Worst Comics Series | Doom Patrol |
| Character Most Deserving of Own Series | Dr. Strange |
| Favorite New Character | Arwyn (Sojourn) |
| Favorite Manga | Oh My Goddess! |
| Favorite Black and White Comic | Cerebus |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Planet of the Apes |
| Hall of Fame | C. Long |
| Zombie of the Year | M. Jacot |
| Favorite Writer | M. Jacot |
| Favorite Artist | M. Jacot |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theater (M. Jacot) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theater #72 (M. Jacot) |
| Best Newcomer | K. Rasmussen & J. Lipecka |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 140 (W. J. Meyer) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 150 |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Whitemare (M. Jacot) |
| APA Member Most Missed | C. Long |
| Favorite Regular Comic Series | Ultimate Spider-Man |
| Favorite Limited Series | League of ExtraOrdinary Gentlemen |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | (7 way tie) Congo: Die Abrafaxe in Afrika; JLA: Earth 2; Killraven; Racer X; Superman: Lex 2000; Universe X 4; World's Funniest |
| Favorite Collected Edition | Crisis On Infinite Earths |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Kurt Busiek |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Al Vey |
| Favorite Cover Artist | Adam Hughes |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Spider-Man |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Non-Sequitor |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Best New Comics Series | Ultimate Spider-Man |
| Worst Comics Series | Marvel Knights |
| Character Most Deserving of Own Series | (6 way tie) Daredevil; Doom; Joker; Ben Reilly; Rogue; Skippy the Jedi Droid |
| Favorite Comics Movie | X-Men |
| Hall of Fame | None |
| Zombie of the Year | A. Olin |
| Favorite Writer | A. Olin |
| Favorite Artist | W. J. Meyer |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theater (M. Jacot) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theater Fall Preview (M. Jacot) |
| Best Newcomer | J. Mertz |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 136 (M. Jacot) |
| Favorite Single Zine Cover | Farmer's Other Almanac 54 (D. Brown) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 136 |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | Post-Mortal (A. Olin) |
| Favorite Comic Series | Daredevil |
| Favorite Limited Series | League of ExtraOrdinary Gentlemen & Contest of Champions II |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | Sandman: The Dream Hunters |
| Favorite Collected Edition | Whiteout |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Kurt Busiek |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Al Vey |
| Favorite Cover Artist | Alex Ross |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Daredevil |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Peanuts |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Best New Comics Series | Spider-Girl |
| Worst Comics Series | Spider-Man: Chapter One |
| Character Most Deserving of Own Series | Harley Quinn |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Star Wars I: The Phantom Menace |
| Hall of Fame | None |
| Zombie of the Year | W. J. Meyer |
| Favorite Writer | W. J. Meyer |
| Favorite Artist | Astrodonna |
| Favorite Regular Zine | Cinematic Jihad (W. J. Meyer) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theater 47 (M. Jacot) |
| Best Newcomer | Astrodonna |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 120 (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Single Zine Cover | The Sunset Times 100 (M. Tart) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 125 |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | White Bread (W. J. Meyer) & Two Silverstaffs (H. Ferreira) |
| Favorite Comic Series | Avengers |
| Favorite Limited Series | Stardust |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | Superman: Peace on Earth |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Kurt Busiek |
| Favorite Comics Artist | George Perez |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Chris Ware |
| Favorite Cover Artist | Alex Ross |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Spider-Man |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Foxtrot |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Best New Comics Series | Martian Manhunter |
| Worst Comics Series | J2 |
| Character Most Deserving of Own Series | Hawkeye |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Blade |
| Hall of Fame | M. Lucas |
| Zombie of the Year | L. Brown |
| Favorite Writer | M. Tart |
| Favorite Artist | C. Long |
| Favorite Regular Zine | The Sunset Times (M. Tart) |
| Favorite Single Zine | Shouting Fire in a Theater Fall Preview (M. Jacot) |
| Best Newcomer | H. Ferreira |
| Favorite Apa Cover | No. 110 (C. Long) |
| Favorite Single Zine Cover | Farmer's Other Almanac 37 (L. Brown) |
| Favorite Apa Issue | No. 108 |
| Favorite Original Apa Story | The Mad Baker Saga (B. Muehl) |
| Favorite Comic Series | Astro City |
| Favorite Limited Series | Uncle Sam |
| Favorite Graphic Novel/One-Shot | Challengers of the Fantastic |
| Favorite Comics Writer | Kurt Busiek |
| Favorite Comics Artist | Chris Bachelo & Alex Ross |
| Favorite Comics Inker | Mark Buckingham |
| Favorite Cover Artist | Alex Ross |
| Favorite Comics Character(s) | Batman |
| Favorite Comics Strip | Dilbert |
| Favorite Publisher/Imprint | DC |
| Best New Comics Series | Thunderbolts |
| Worst Comics Series | Heroes For Hire |
| Favorite Comics Movie | Men in Black & George of the Jungle |
| Favorite Rendition of Wolverine | Chris Claremont |
| Hall of Fame | R. Hough |
